The benefits to you of a contrarian investment strategy

Mar 6, 2019 | Tony Byrne's View

Back in the nineties there was a fund manager called Johnson Fry who specialised in innovative, exciting, high risk, tax efficient investments. It was led by Charles Fry who eventually sold it to Legg Mason in 2000.

One of its most interesting funds was the M&G Worst Performance Fund which was launched in 1992. Johnson Fry simply invested 100% of the fund at the beginning of January each year into the worst performing M&G fund of the previous calendar year. They repeated this strategy year after year. Up until the late nineties it outperformed the UK stock market comfortably, but by the year 2000 it started to lose its lustre and eventually it became absorbed into a Legg Mason managed fund. It was fun while it lasted.

We adopted a momentum strategy some years which we called Dynamic Fund Control. It was based on 8 weeks’ and 6 months’ moving averages. Basically, the single fund with the best performance over both of these periods would be chosen and 100% would be invested into it. As soon as another fund’s momentum overtook it based on the 2 moving averages the new fund would be chosen to replace the existing fund. It was a rolling moving averages system.

This system, like the M&G Worst Performance Fund, worked brilliantly for many years and at one stage was averaging a return of 22% per annum. We relied on the fund performance data from a third party which was a small organisation. Unfortunately, the founder retired, the quality of the data deteriorated and the system no longer produced high returns. We decided to stop using the third party and were forced to stop offering the service. Again, it was fun while it lasted.

Johnson Fry also launched a fund called Hy5. This was based on Michael O’Higgins’ famous Five-stock Dogs of the Dow approach which worked as follows:

  • Once you have determined the 10 highest yielding Dow Jones Index stocks, identify the five with the lowest closing prices and invest an equal dollar amount in each stock;
  • Rebalance the portfolio periodically by again investing an equal dollar amount in each of the five highest yielding, lowest priced Dow Jones industrial stocks at that time.

It must be noted that a five-stock portfolio lacks diversification, making it much more vulnerable to a major setback in one particular stock.

Johnson Fry completely copied this approach but based it on the FTSE 100 Index instead. It outperformed for a while then lost its way. Yet again, it was fun while it lasted.

The interesting point here is that a contrarian approach can produce fantastic returns, even one that involves putting all of your eggs in one basket or in the above examples in one fund rather than typically 15 funds. However, if you are going to put all of your eggs in one basket you must watch that basket closely.

In my experience these contrarian strategies do work but they do not always necessarily have a long shelf life. So why take a chance? Instead, why not invest your money into our sister company, Minerva Money Management’s fund, The CCM Intelligent Wealth Fund? It invests in innovative and disruptive companies that are shaping our future across 9 investment sectors of the future, which we have heavily researched over the last 3 years. If you are looking to invest in potentially high growth companies of the future why invest in anything else?

So if you’d like advice on how best to invest your money, get in touch with us. You know it makes sense.

Our Scorecards

Try out our quick and free assessments; your personalised reports will instantly be created.

Useful guides

We've created two useful documents to help you find a Independent Financial Adviser and make sure you get the most from them.

16 Questions To Ask Your Independent Financial Adviser

How to find an Independent Financial Adviser

    To download this file, please fill in your information below.